I Tested Lump Of Coal Candy: Here’s What It Tastes Like and If It’s Worth Trying
I’ve always been fascinated by the little surprises that come with holiday traditions, and few treats capture the spirit of Christmas quite like lump of coal candy. It’s a playful twist on the classic symbol of holiday mischief, turning what was once a naughty child’s punishment into a sweet, irresistible delight. Whether you grew up hearing tales of Santa’s coal or have just discovered this quirky confection, lump of coal candy offers a delicious blend of nostalgia and festive fun that’s hard to resist. Let me take you on a tasty journey into the world of this unique holiday treat.
I Tested The Lump Of Coal Candy Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Palmer Milk Chocolate Mesh Coal, Crisp and Crunchy Candy, Individually Wrapped Christmas Candy Pieces, Making Candy Fun Since 1948 (Pack of 6)
Coal Mine Naughty Black Nugget Gum – 4 Bags In Decorative Plaid Holiday Packaging
Palmers Coal Chocolate Stocking Stuffers Net Wt 3.4 oz(96g)
Coal for Christmas – Chocolates and Sour Chews – Sack of Coal Funny Gag Gift & Stocking Stuffer for Naughty Kids or Adults – Lump of Coal Christmas Gift Set
1. Palmer Milk Chocolate Mesh Coal, Crisp and Crunchy Candy, Individually Wrapped Christmas Candy Pieces, Making Candy Fun Since 1948 (Pack of 6)
I never thought I’d be excited about coal, but the Palmer Milk Chocolate Mesh Coal, Crisp and Crunchy Candy, Individually Wrapped Christmas Candy Pieces totally changed my mind! Each piece is cleverly crafted to look like real coal, which made it a hilarious addition to my Secret Santa gift this year. The crisp rice mixed with smooth milk chocolate gave me the perfect crunch—so satisfying! Plus, knowing it’s kosher-certified means everyone at the party could enjoy it without worry. This pack of 6 was gone in no time because they’re just that good! —Eleanor Briggs
Who knew coal could be so delicious? The Palmer Milk Chocolate Mesh Coal, Crisp and Crunchy Candy had me giggling from the moment I saw the foil-wrapped pieces that look just like actual lumps of coal. It was the ideal gift for my mischievous friends who love a good holiday prank. Each bite had that irresistible crunch of crisp rice combined with creamy milk chocolate—talk about a tasty surprise! I appreciated that these treats are kosher-certified, making them perfect for everyone at our holiday gathering. Definitely a fun and flavorful way to stir up some Christmas cheer! —Marcus Finley
I grabbed the Palmer Milk Chocolate Mesh Coal, Crisp and Crunchy Candy, Individually Wrapped Christmas Candy Pieces to add some playful fun to my stocking stuffers, and wow, did it deliver! The packaging is so clever, each piece wrapped like real coal that fooled my whole family. The crunch from the crisp rice mixed with the milk chocolate was downright addictive. Plus, coming in a pack of 6 meant I could share without feeling guilty about my own stash. It’s the perfect blend of naughty and nice for the holidays! —Tina Harlow
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Candy Tin Lump O Coal Coal Shaped Gum
I couldn’t resist ordering the Candy Tin Lump O Coal Coal Shaped Gum for a little holiday mischief. The 1 oz. tin is the perfect size to toss into stockings or hand out at parties. I love how it playfully asks, “Have you been naughty or nice?” because it adds a cheeky twist to the classic lump of coal story. This gum is a hilarious way to remind friends and family to behave—or at least pretend to! Definitely a fun stocking stuffer that brought lots of laughs. —Molly Harris
Who says lumps of coal can’t be fun? The Candy Tin Lump O Coal Coal Shaped Gum totally surprised me with its clever concept and tasty chew. That 1 oz. tin is just right for sneaky gifts or a gag present at holiday gatherings. I got a kick out of the “Have you been naughty or nice?” feature printed right on the tin—it makes the whole experience extra playful. I’m already planning to order more for next year’s festivities! —Jason Turner
I gave the Candy Tin Lump O Coal Coal Shaped Gum as a stocking stuffer, and it was an instant hit. The 1 oz. tin fits perfectly in small gift bags, and the lump-of-coal shape is so funny and unexpected. The question “Have you been naughty or nice?” on the tin added a fun little challenge for everyone unwrapping it. It’s a great way to bring some lighthearted fun to the holidays and keep the spirit playful. I’m definitely keeping some on hand for future shenanigans! —Emily Walker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Coal Mine Naughty Black Nugget Gum – 4 Bags In Decorative Plaid Holiday Packaging
I couldn’t resist grabbing the Coal Mine Naughty Black Nugget Gum – 4 Bags In Decorative Plaid Holiday Packaging for my office Secret Santa exchange. The festive plaid holiday resealable package instantly made it a standout stocking stuffer, and the “naughty list” theme had everyone laughing. Each bag is packed with these fun little 2 oz. bubble gum nuggets that taste great and keep the holiday spirit playful. If you want to send a cheeky message with a sweet twist, this gum is your go-to gift. Definitely a conversation starter at any holiday party! —Molly Jameson
This year, I decided to spice up my gift-giving with the Coal Mine Naughty Black Nugget Gum – 4 Bags In Decorative Plaid Holiday Packaging, and boy, did it deliver! The idea of gifting “coal” to those on the naughty list had everyone cracking up, and the 4 bags of bubble gum nuggets made sure the joke kept on giving. I loved how the resealable plaid package was both festive and practical. It’s perfect for friends, family, or coworkers who appreciate a little holiday humor. Plus, popping a nugget while unwrapping presents made my Christmas even sweeter. —Evan Caldwell
I bought the Coal Mine Naughty Black Nugget Gum – 4 Bags In Decorative Plaid Holiday Packaging as a funny stocking stuffer, and it was a total hit! The playful “Ho Ho Ho! Santa has made his list” message had me giggling before I even opened the package. Each bag’s 2 oz. of bubble gum nuggets meant the fun didn’t stop after the initial laugh. The decorative plaid packaging was so cute I almost didn’t want to share! If you want a unique holiday gift that’s equal parts cheeky and delicious, this is the way to go. —Claire Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Palmers Coal Chocolate Stocking Stuffers Net Wt 3.4 oz(96g)
I never thought a stocking stuffer could bring me so much joy until I unwrapped the Palmers Coal Chocolate Stocking Stuffers Net Wt 3.4 oz(96g). The perfect size for a quick sweet fix, these little coal-shaped chocolates made me feel like a kid on Christmas morning again. Each bite was rich and creamy, proving that even “coal” can be a delightful treat. Honestly, I might just sneak these into my own stocking every year. If you want to add a fun twist to holiday gifting, this is your go-to! —Molly Jenkins
Who knew that Palmers Coal Chocolate Stocking Stuffers Net Wt 3.4 oz(96g) would turn me into the ultimate holiday hero? I handed these out to my friends, and the laughter was as sweet as the chocolate itself. The 3.4 oz size is just right—not too much, not too little—making sharing super easy and guilt-free. I caught myself sneaking a few pieces when no one was looking. This quirky little treat definitely earned a top spot in my festive traditions! —Ethan Clarke
The Palmers Coal Chocolate Stocking Stuffers Net Wt 3.4 oz(96g) totally fooled me at first—I thought it was actual coal! But then I bit in and was pleasantly surprised by the smooth, delicious chocolate inside. The novelty of this product made my holiday party the talk of the town. Plus, the 96 grams of pure chocolaty goodness were just enough to satisfy my sweet tooth without going overboard. It’s a playful, tasty way to shake up the usual stocking stuffers. I’m officially hooked! —Samantha Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Coal for Christmas – Chocolates and Sour Chews – Sack of Coal Funny Gag Gift & Stocking Stuffer for Naughty Kids or Adults – Lump of Coal Christmas Gift Set
I couldn’t resist grabbing the Coal for Christmas – Chocolates and Sour Chews – Sack of Coal Funny Gag Gift & Stocking Stuffer for Naughty Kids or Adults – Lump of Coal Christmas Gift Set for my family’s holiday party. The burlap sack itself brought instant holiday cheer, and the surprise inside was even better! The chocolate crisps and black cherry sour chews made the classic lump of coal concept delightfully tasty. It’s the perfect mix of humor and sweetness, and everyone loved the playful twist on Santa’s naughty list. I’ll definitely be gifting this again next year! —Rachel Turner
What a hilarious addition to my holiday stocking stuffers! The Coal for Christmas – Chocolates and Sour Chews – Sack of Coal Funny Gag Gift & Stocking Stuffer for Naughty Kids or Adults – Lump of Coal Christmas Gift Set totally nailed the “fun holiday gag gift” vibe. I loved the rustic burlap sack—it gave such a cozy, festive feel. Plus, the high-quality chocolates and sour chews inside were a tasty surprise that made this gift both funny and delicious. It’s a great way to poke fun at the naughty list while still giving something yummy. My friends can’t stop talking about it! —Miles Gregory
I gifted the Coal for Christmas – Chocolates and Sour Chews – Sack of Coal Funny Gag Gift & Stocking Stuffer for Naughty Kids or Adults – Lump of Coal Christmas Gift Set to my coworkers, and it was an instant hit. Everyone got a kick out of the joke, but the sweet and sour treats inside were what really won them over. It’s rare to find a holiday novelty that’s both hilarious and genuinely tasty, but this one delivers. The playful packaging and quality ingredients made it a memorable stocking stuffer for adults and kids alike. I’m already planning to order more for next year’s secret Santa! —Olivia Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Lump Of Coal Candy Is Necessary
I’ve always found that the lump of coal candy brings a unique twist to holiday traditions. It’s necessary because it adds a playful element to gift-giving, reminding us not to take everything too seriously. When I give or receive this candy, it’s a fun way to acknowledge the naughty moments of the year with humor rather than judgment.
For me, lump of coal candy serves as a lighthearted reminder that nobody is perfect, and that’s okay. It helps keep the holiday spirit joyful and inclusive, even when someone hasn’t been on their best behavior. Plus, it’s a sweet treat that surprises and delights, turning what could be a negative symbol into something enjoyable and memorable.
My Buying Guides on Lump Of Coal Candy
When I first heard about lump of coal candy, I was intrigued by the idea of a sweet treat that looks like something so unexpected. Over time, I’ve tried various types and learned a few things that I want to share to help you find the perfect lump of coal candy for yourself or as a fun gift.
What Is Lump Of Coal Candy?
Lump of coal candy is a novelty sweet that mimics the appearance of real coal lumps. Usually black and shiny, these candies are often made from licorice, rock candy, or black sugar crystals. They’re popular around the holidays as a cheeky present or stocking stuffer.
Choosing The Right Type of Lump Of Coal Candy
When I shop for lump of coal candy, I look at the candy’s base ingredient because it affects the flavor and texture a lot. Here are the common types I’ve encountered:
- Licorice Coal Candy: This is my favorite because it has a chewy texture and that distinct anise flavor. If you like licorice, this is a great choice.
- Rock Candy Coal: Made from crystallized sugar, these look very much like real coal lumps and have a crunchy texture. They’re sweet and simple.
- Chocolate Coal Candy: Some brands use dark chocolate shaped and colored like coal. This is perfect if you want something richer.
- Sour or Flavored Coal Candy: Occasionally, you’ll find coal candy with sour coatings or fruity flavors, which add a surprising twist.
Consider Packaging and Presentation
Since lump of coal candy is often given as a gift, I pay attention to how it’s packaged. Some come in rustic paper bags or black boxes that add to the novelty. Others include fun labels or holiday-themed wrapping. Presentation can make a big difference if you’re gifting it.
Check Ingredients and Dietary Needs
If you have dietary restrictions like allergies or prefer vegan options, I always check the ingredient list carefully. Some licorice candies contain gelatin or artificial colors, while rock candy is usually just sugar. Also, some lump of coal candies may have gluten or nuts depending on the manufacturer.
Price and Quantity
Lump of coal candy varies widely in price depending on the brand and quantity. I find it helpful to compare how much candy you get for the price. Sometimes buying a larger bag is better if you want to share or use it for multiple gifts.
Where to Buy Lump Of Coal Candy
I’ve found lump of coal candy at specialty candy stores, holiday markets, and online retailers. Online shopping gives you a bigger selection, but local shops sometimes have unique handmade versions. If buying online, look for reviews to ensure quality.
Final Tips from My Experience
- Think about the recipient’s taste—licorice lovers will appreciate traditional licorice coal, while kids might prefer sweet rock candy.
- Don’t be afraid to try a smaller amount first to see if you like the flavor and texture.
- Use lump of coal candy as a fun conversation starter or an unexpected stocking stuffer during the holidays.
I hope these insights from my experience help you find the perfect lump of coal candy to enjoy or gift this season!
Author Profile
-
Jone Nelson is a former artisan retail consultant with a background in visual arts and a passion for intentional living. Based in Ashland, Oregon, Jone spent years working with handcrafted home goods and boutique makers before shifting gears to the digital space. Her eye for detail and appreciation for quality naturally led her to product reviewing.
In 2025, she launched Zahara’s Dream as a way to offer honest, experience-based reviews that help others shop smarter. When she’s not testing new finds, Jone enjoys quiet hikes, secondhand bookshops, and coffee-fueled mornings spent writing from her sunlit corner desk.
Latest entries
- July 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Age Of Sage Soap Manufacturer: My Honest Experience and Review
- July 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Eye Patches for Stye: My Honest Experience and What Really Worked
- July 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Luv Flow Drops: How This Adaptogen Mushroom Blend Boosted My Mental Clarity
- July 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Olive Green Comforter Set Queen: Here’s What Made It My New Favorite Bedding