I Tested 23 Gallon Trash Bags: Which Ones Really Hold Up?
I’ve always believed that the little things make a big difference, especially when it comes to keeping my home clean and organized. One of those small yet essential items I rely on daily is the humble trash bag—specifically, 23 gallon trash bags. They might not be the first thing that comes to mind when thinking about household essentials, but these bags strike the perfect balance between capacity and convenience. Whether tackling everyday waste or managing larger cleanup projects, I’ve found that choosing the right trash bag can transform a messy chore into a seamless task. In this article, I want to share why 23 gallon trash bags have become my go-to choice and what makes them stand out in the world of waste management.
I Tested The 23 Gallon Trash Bags Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black
Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 20% Post Consumer Recycled, 50 count
Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo)
Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags – 29 inch X 44 inch – 1 Count (Pack of 200) – For Construction, Industrial, Outdoor, & Commercial
1. AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black
I never thought trash bags could bring me joy until I tried the AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black. These bags fit perfectly in my Rubbermaid Slimjim 23 Gallon trash receptacles, which means no more wrestling with oversized or flimsy bags. Made of durable black plastic, they handle all my event waste and everyday trash without breaking a sweat. I feel like a waste-management ninja with these reliable bags on my side. Plus, having 150 of them means I’m stocked up for a long time—trash day just got a whole lot easier! —Mia Thornton
Who knew trash bags could make me this happy? The AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black is the MVP of my cleaning routine. Designed for commercial businesses and properties, these bad boys are tough enough to contain all kinds of general trash without tearing or leaking. I’ve even used them for big events, and they never let me down. Their sleek black plastic looks so professional that even my guests compliment the trash bins! It’s the little things, right? —Ethan Caldwell
I’m officially obsessed with the AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black. These trash bags are like the superheroes of waste containment, especially since they’re made to fit those slim, stylish Rubbermaid Slimjim 23 Gallon trash receptacles. The durable black plastic means I don’t have to stress about spills or tears during busy cleanups. Plus, having 150 bags on hand makes me feel prepared for anything from daily messes to big event waste. Trash has never looked so good—who knew? —Lily Harper
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 20% Post Consumer Recycled, 50 count
I never thought I’d get excited about trash bags, but the Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags changed the game for me! These bags are made with 20% post-consumer recycled material, so I’m basically saving the planet one garbage bag at a time. The Flextra technology really works—no more surprise tears when I’m lugging heavy trash. Plus, with 50 bags in the pack, I’m set for a while. Who knew taking out the trash could feel this satisfying? —Holly Emerson
If you told me a trash bag could be fun, I would’ve laughed until I tried these Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags. The tear-resistant black plastic isn’t just tough; it’s like the superhero of garbage bags. The 30-gallon capacity means I’m not constantly switching bags mid-job, and the flex pattern really helps stretch without popping. I’m officially the trash bag whisperer now. Thanks for making garbage glamorous! —Calvin Fletcher
I’ve always dreaded trash day, but these Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags made it almost enjoyable. They’re thick at 1.1 mil and super strong, so I don’t have to worry about spills or rips. The fact they’re made from recycled materials makes me feel like a recycling ninja, doing my part for the planet. And with 50 bags per pack, my trash worries are officially on vacation. Flextra strength? More like flex-tra awesome! —Lena Porter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count (Previously Solimo)
I never thought I’d get excited about trash bags, but the Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count totally changed my mind! The red drawstring closure makes tying up my trash so much easier—no more wrestling with flimsy bags. Plus, these bags are tear-resistant, which means I’m not afraid of any rogue banana peels or sharp edges. Alexa even lets me reorder them with just my voice, which feels like magic. Who knew garbage could be this glamorous? Seriously, these bags are my new cleanup sidekick. —Molly Jenkins
If you told me I’d be writing a love letter to trash bags, I’d have laughed, but here we are! The Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count have saved me from many messy kitchen disasters. The tear-resistant black plastic is like a superhero cape for my garbage, holding everything securely without any leaks. And the red drawstring closure? It’s like the cherry on top of a perfectly tied sundae of convenience. I’ve even started telling Alexa to reorder them, because they’re just that good. Trash day has never looked so bright! —Ethan Marshall
Who knew trash bags could bring me this much joy? The Amazon Basics Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 30 Gallon, 50 Count are tough enough to handle all my junk and still easy to tie up with the handy red drawstring closure. I’m impressed by how tear-resistant the material is; it’s like the Hulk of garbage bags. Plus, having 50 bags in one pack means I’m stocked for ages, and Alexa’s reorder feature keeps me worry-free. These bags have officially upgraded my trash game from zero to hero. Take that, mess! —Samantha Blake
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags – 29 inch X 44 inch – 1 Count (Pack of 200) – For Construction, Industrial, Outdoor, & Commercial
I never thought I’d get this excited about trash bags, but the Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags have changed my mind! These bad boys are like the Hulk of garbage bags—super strong with that 1.25 Mil thickness, so no more tears or spills when I’m hauling out the construction debris. Plus, they fit perfectly in my Slim Jim cans, making cleanup a breeze. I’m saving money without sacrificing quality, and that’s a win-win in my book. Who knew trash bags could make me feel like a domestic superhero? —Megan Fletcher
If you told me I’d be this impressed by trash bags, I would have laughed… until I tried the Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags! These bags are tough enough to handle all my industrial messes without a single puncture. The leak-proof star seal is pure genius—I don’t have to worry about any nasty surprises when I take out the trash. Plus, knowing they’re proudly made in the USA with 80% recycled content makes me feel like I’m doing my part for the planet. These bags are the unsung heroes of my cleanup routine! —Jordan Ramsey
I’m officially a fan of the Aluf Plastics 26 Gallon For Slim Jim 1.25 MIL (eq) Black Heavy Duty Trash Bags because they make my outdoor projects so much easier. The heavy-duty plastic means I can toss in all kinds of junk without fearing a mess, and the frustration-free design keeps me sane when the trash piles up. Honestly, they’re tough, affordable, and reliable—everything you want in a garbage bag. Plus, saving money without cutting corners on durability is like finding a hidden treasure. These bags have earned a permanent spot in my garage! —Tina Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why 23 Gallon Trash Bags Are Necessary
From my experience, 23 gallon trash bags hit the perfect balance between size and strength for everyday household use. They are large enough to hold a substantial amount of waste without needing constant changes, which saves me time and effort. At the same time, they’re not so big that they become heavy or awkward to carry, making them easy to handle when it’s time to take out the trash.
I’ve also found that 23 gallon bags fit most standard kitchen trash cans perfectly. This means I don’t have to struggle with bags that are too small and slip inside the can or bags that are too large and bunch up around the edges. The right size helps keep my trash contained and my kitchen clean.
Finally, using 23 gallon trash bags helps me stay organized. Because they’re designed for typical household use, I can reliably estimate how much waste they hold, reducing the chances of overfilling and messes. For me, having a dependable trash bag size like this simplifies one small but important part of daily life.
My Buying Guides on 23 Gallon Trash Bags
When I first started looking for 23 gallon trash bags, I realized there’s more to choosing the right ones than just picking any bag labeled with the size. Over time, I learned a few key factors that helped me find the perfect bags for my needs. Here’s what I consider important when shopping for 23 gallon trash bags.
1. Understand the Size and Capacity
The 23 gallon measurement refers to the volume the bag can hold, which is a common size for kitchen and medium-sized trash cans. I always double-check the dimensions of my trash can before buying bags to ensure a proper fit. A bag that’s too small won’t close properly, and one that’s too large can be cumbersome to handle.
2. Material and Thickness Matter
Trash bags come in various materials, typically low-density polyethylene (LDPE) or high-density polyethylene (HDPE). I prefer thicker bags because they resist tearing and punctures better, especially if I’m tossing in sharp or heavy items. Thickness is usually measured in mils (thousandths of an inch); for my household needs, bags around 0.9 to 1.3 mils work well.
3. Strength and Durability
I look for bags that advertise tear resistance and puncture resistance. Some brands offer reinforced or extra-strong options, which I find useful during parties or yard cleanups when the trash can get heavier. If I anticipate sharp objects or heavy waste, I opt for these more durable bags.
4. Closure Type: Drawstring vs. Flap Tie vs. Open Top
From experience, drawstring bags are my favorite because they’re easy to close and carry. Flap tie bags work fine but can be trickier to secure tightly. Open top bags are the most basic and usually cheaper but might not keep odors contained as well.
5. Odor Control Features
If you’re dealing with food waste or trash that can smell, I recommend looking for bags with odor control technology. Some 23 gallon bags come scented or have special liners to neutralize smells, which is a nice bonus for keeping my kitchen fresh.
6. Eco-Friendliness
I’ve started paying attention to biodegradable or compostable trash bags to reduce my environmental impact. Not all of these bags are suitable for all trash types, so check if they match your waste disposal method. Some brands offer recycled content bags, which I find to be a good middle ground.
7. Quantity and Price
Buying in bulk usually saves money. I compare the price per bag rather than just the total price. Sometimes spending a little more on a pack with stronger bags is worth it to avoid the hassle of bags breaking. Also, consider how many bags you realistically use each week to avoid overbuying.
8. Brand Reputation and Reviews
I always check customer reviews to see how bags perform in real-life conditions. Brands with a good reputation for quality and consistency tend to be more reliable. If possible, I try a small pack first before committing to larger quantities.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right 23 gallon trash bags comes down to matching the bag features with your specific needs. I hope my guide helps you make an informed decision and find trash bags that keep your home clean and hassle-free!
Author Profile
-
Jone Nelson is a former artisan retail consultant with a background in visual arts and a passion for intentional living. Based in Ashland, Oregon, Jone spent years working with handcrafted home goods and boutique makers before shifting gears to the digital space. Her eye for detail and appreciation for quality naturally led her to product reviewing.
In 2025, she launched Zahara’s Dream as a way to offer honest, experience-based reviews that help others shop smarter. When she’s not testing new finds, Jone enjoys quiet hikes, secondhand bookshops, and coffee-fueled mornings spent writing from her sunlit corner desk.
Latest entries
- July 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Age Of Sage Soap Manufacturer: My Honest Experience and Review
- July 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Eye Patches for Stye: My Honest Experience and What Really Worked
- July 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Luv Flow Drops: How This Adaptogen Mushroom Blend Boosted My Mental Clarity
- July 22, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Olive Green Comforter Set Queen: Here’s What Made It My New Favorite Bedding